ATS pricing comparison: subscription vs usage-based, for UK care providers
TL;DR: For a typical UK care provider hiring 10–20 people per month, the biggest hiring cost isn't the ATS licence. It's the agency spend that a subscription ATS doesn't replace. Usage-based pricing, where you pay for the screening, interviews and checks the platform actually runs, means you stop paying for idle seats and can cut agency fees. Here's a full side-by-side.
The four pricing models
| Model | How it works | Typical UK price | Good for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Per-user / per-seat | £ per user per month | £50–£300 / user / mo | Small teams, steady hiring |
| Per-job / requisition | £ per active vacancy per month | £50–£500 / role / mo | Low, predictable hiring volume |
| Flat-rate / enterprise | Fixed £ per year, all-in | £20k–£100k / year | Large, complex organisations |
| Usage-based (tokens) | You pay for the work the platform does | Quoted to your hiring volume | Care providers hiring regularly |
Side-by-side worked example
Scenario: a 5-site residential care provider hiring 15 care workers a month. 4 managers using the system.
Option A — Per-seat ATS + agency
- 4 seats × £150 / month = £600 / month (£7,200 / year)
- 7 hires via agency × £4,500 per placement = £31,500 / month (£378k / year)
- Implementation: £5,000 year one
- Training: 2 days, £1,500
- Year one total: ~£392k
Option B — Flat-rate enterprise ATS + agency
- £3,000 / month platform = £36,000 / year
- 7 hires via agency × £4,500 per placement = £378,000 / year
- Implementation: £15,000 year one
- Year one total: ~£429k
Option C — Lily Hire (usage-based)
- You pay for the work Lily does: screening calls, interviews and compliance checks
- No seats, no subscription, no setup fee
- Implementation: included
- Training: included
- Agency spend: most of it replaced, because Lily sources and screens direct
- Year one total: sized to your hiring volume. Ask us for pricing in a demo.
Numbers for options A and B are illustrative, based on typical UK agency placement fees for care workers (£3,750–£6,250) and published ATS pricing.
Why subscription ATS costs so much more in practice
The hidden line is agency spend.
A subscription ATS is a filing cabinet. It doesn't actually source or screen candidates at scale. Most care providers using a subscription ATS still pay agency fees because they still can't reliably fill vacancies direct. The ATS bill is small; the agency bill is enormous.
Usage-based pricing covers the full pipeline. Sourcing, screening, scheduling, compliance, onboarding — you pay for the work the platform actually does, not for seats sitting idle.
Other factors worth comparing
- Implementation time. Subscription ATS: 1–6 months. Enterprise: 6–12 months. Lily: under 1 week.
- Admin time. Subscription ATS: still need to run phone screens manually. Lily: phone screening is automated.
- Audit trail. Varies widely. CQC-ready records are default in Lily, extra work elsewhere.
- Lock-in. Most enterprise ATS contracts are 2–3 years minimum. Lily has no minimum term.
When subscription still makes sense
For organisations hiring a small number of senior, complex, or highly specialised roles, per-seat subscription ATS products are still fine. For high-volume, time-sensitive, compliance-heavy hiring — i.e. UK care — a platform that does the screening and checks for you, priced by usage, almost always wins.
Frequently asked questions
How is Lily priced?
Lily is priced by usage. You buy tokens and spend them on the work Lily does, from screening calls to compliance checks. There's no per-seat licence, no subscription, no setup fee and no minimum term. Ask us for pricing in a demo and we'll size it to your hiring volume.
What about Lily Screen?
Lily Screen is for teams that want to keep their own ATS and just use Lily for phone screening. It's priced by usage too.
Can I switch from a subscription ATS to Lily mid-contract?
Yes. Most providers run them in parallel for a month during migration.
Is there a minimum spend?
No. There's no subscription, no minimum spend and no minimum term.
Next step
Sources: Sonderwell 12-month case study. UK agency placement fee benchmarks (Skills for Care, REC 2024). Published ATS vendor pricing.
Get care sector hiring insights straight to your inbox
Join care providers across the UK who read our practical guides on recruitment, retention, and compliance, delivered straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.